Saturday, August 17, 2013

Egypt Will Be Saved by the Army or Lost to Radical Islam

Dear readers, I am more and more disturbed by what the media is saying and what experts speaking to or writing in the media are saying - about Egypt. The perfect example...today, an article in The American Conservative beats the title : "Cut Egypt Loose." As if Egypt were a derelict rowboat that should be allowed to sink. The post quotes an earlier article which said : "With blood in Egypt’s streets and a return to a state of emergency, it’s time for Washington to stop pretending. Its efforts to maintain its lines of communication with the Egyptian military, quietly mediate the crisis, and help lay the groundwork for some new, democratic political process have utterly failed. Egypt’s new military regime, and a sizable and vocal portion of the Egyptian population, have made it very clear that they just want the United States to leave it alone. For once, Washington should give them their wish. As long as Egypt remains on its current path, the Obama administration should suspend all aid, keep the embassy in Cairo closed, and refrain from treating the military regime as a legitimate government." In "Cut Egypt Loose" the writer agrees with this conclusion : "It might have seemed clever to withhold judgment on the July coup and try to nudge the military towards a return to elected government, but this was interpreted by all sides as a positive endorsement of the coup and confirmation that there was nothing that the Egyptian military did that would trigger the suspension of aid....The U.S. can’t constructively influence what the Egyptian military and its interim government do, and it should stop pretending that it can....it does nothing but harm America’s reputation to be backing a coup government that kills civilian protesters in the streets. It costs the U.S. very little to end that support, and it gains the U.S. nothing but grief to continue the status quo." ~~~~~ THIS IS WRONG...WRONG...WRONG. We are not witnessing in the Moslem Brotherhood a new Martin Luther King trying to gain constitutionally guaranteed civil rights for American Blacks. This is not Selma or the March on the Mall. The Moslem Brotherhood does not have "a dream." It is attempting to impose a nightmare on Egyptians who do not support their radical vision of Islam. The Moslem Brotherhood spawned Hamas - the organization that "kidnapped" the Palestinians of the Gaza Strip by promising democracy and economic development but delivering charia law, imposed leaders without further elections and economic collapse. Morsi tried to "kidnap" Egypt with a similar set of election promises. He then hired corrupt security forces to monitor civilians. He rigged the parliamentary elections and foisted an islamist-charia leaning constitution on Egyptians who were cut out of the governmental process. He gave himself dictarorial powers. BUT Morsi made one mistake. He thought Egyptians were as docile as the Gaza Palestinians. They were not. Egyptians rose up in the tens of millions to demand that the army get rid of Morsi and let them restart their march toward self-government. WHAT HAS THE ARMY DONE? The army stepped in. It took Morsi from power. It named an interim government after consulting all groups in Egypt. It announced a plan, still on schedule, to write a new constitution, approve it in a referendum and then hold parliamentary and presidential elections. The interim prime minister today reaffirmed all this in a TV appearance. WHAT HAS THE BROTHERHOOD DONE? It has encouraged its followers to block significant crossroads making some Cairo areas difficult to live and work in, while torturirg and killing some who refused to join the Brotherhood. It has pleaded that it is the innocent democratic victim...just re-read above to understand the cynicism at work here. It collected arms, ammunition and bombs - many of which have been seized by the army this week. It has desecrated and burned Christian churches. It has killed a cab driver who supported the army with a photo in his taxi. It has beheaded at least one policeman. It occupied a mosque and used tbe prayer minaret as a vantage point for sniper fire on citizens and soldiers in the streets - the army offered safe exit to Brotherhood followers and others in the mosque and helped many exit before clearing it of Brotherhood members today. ~~~~~ Yes...the army has killed people this week. Yes...the situation is precarious. BUT imagine the massacres all over Egypt if the army loses control to the Brotherhood. Imagine an Egypt controlled by islamist radicals. Imagine the future of the Suez Canal. Imagine Iran in Egypt with no restraining force left to keep them and the Brotherhood and Hamas from making good on their vow to eliminate Israel. The world is not Utopia. Choices must be made. Choose the dream of self-government for Egypt. Do not cast out her people into the arms of terrorists. Support the Egyptian army as it tries to hold the country together.

9 comments:

  1. Your spot on Casey Pops. One does not throw out the baby with the bath water.

    To rid Egypt of the Brotherhood, to ship them out to some waiting backward thinking country would be a deed well done. Iran comes to mind initially.

    Is the Egyptian Military the perfect choice for Egypt in the long run ...NO. Would it be for almost any democratic seeking country ... NO.

    But ladies and gentlemen it is a start down long road to independence, personal freedoms, religious freedoms, gender equality that must be travelled now or maybe never.

    ReplyDelete
  2. I am the furthest person that could be misconstrued as a "fatalists". But I do believe that the future looks bleak for those poor Middle Easterners that find now to be the time to break the bonds that have so limited their and the generations before them for eons.

    There is always hope and a chance for victory. All is not lost if you can get up and fight the good fight one more time.

    But if the GOOD PEOPLE are left out in the cold, on their own, to their on devices the chore will be difficult and to reach the freedom and liberties that are the prize at the apex of the mountain much more difficult than the the chore should be.

    Now the ONE THING that in my mind would change this doom full scenario would be the active support from the US and various other democratic nations or at least strong vocal endorsement in words, equipment, food supplies, and increased military aide.

    To turn the Radical Islamic into being the minority voice located in a very few countries is not an overnight task. If we must go to bed with the military in various countries, make sure we are dealing with honorable and honest men who want what the citizens want then so be it. But these military governments must no be allowed to stay one day longer than the people want them in power.

    ReplyDelete
  3. Casey Pops poses 3 good rhetorical questions (as always) at the end:

    "The world is not Utopia. Choices must be made. Choose the dream of self-government for Egypt. Do not cast out her people into the arms of terrorists. Support the Egyptian army as it tries to hold the country together"

    Search your hearts and soul over this. Who are we today?

    Are we a society of unconcerned takers and users. Do we No longer believe that if we take from the system we must also help replenish it. Because Egypt is half way around the world (and not in our backyard) do we have No obligation to help the good people of the Middle East. Do we only see that which is directly in front of us and nothing to either side.

    A long term military run government is not the answer. But the Brotherhood in control for eons to come is certainly not unacceptable to the free world.

    Have we thought about the effects of a Brotherhood Egypt? Part of Egypt is over 30% Christian, what will become of those people. What about the effects on world wide commence if the Suez Canal is suddenly made inoperable and/or under sole control of the Muslim Brotherhood.

    What is the regional impact? Is Israel at all safe and defensible even by US forces. Consider the Nuclear impact of Iran in the region.

    We need to be involved in this, even if my dear friend ex-congressmen Ron Paul believes that we should be somewhat "isolationists" towards the world.

    Perhaps the immediate presence of a coalition of US, English, French, and German soldiers suddenly on the streets of Cairo next week would bring all the (so called) rebellious people out of their homes and into the street. A show of strength and support. They are not even getting that right now.

    NOW is not the time for any form of ISOLATIONISM on our part Mr. President. Forget about your legacy and do the right things. And just perhaps you'll have a positive legacy as your reward.

    ReplyDelete
  4. My Grandfathers ChildAugust 18, 2013 at 11:09 AM

    Everyone has the internal desire to leave something tangible and of some value behind when he dies. Something that you touched, developed, or nurtured. perhaps a tree. And when people look at that tree years later it's you they see.

    It doesn't matter what it is just so so you changed it in a positive manner. The difference between the man just does nothing with his tree and relies on nature and the man who prunes, waters, trims his tree. The man who depended on nature might just have not ever been here. The effect of the the man who nurtured his tree will be there for many life times.

    Ernest Hemingway in his "For Whom the Bells Toll" wrote ..."don't ask for whom the bell tolls , it tolls for you"

    We can make this world right again if we want. And maybe that is what this turmoil is all about in the world today. Is our will and decency being tested again as my dear Grandfather us to say looking skyward - "Your testing me again aren't you"

    ReplyDelete
  5. Stand Up And Be CountedAugust 18, 2013 at 1:56 PM

    "It is not the critic who counts; not the man who points out how the strong man stumbles, or where the doer of deeds could have done them better. The credit belongs to the man who is actually in the arena, whose face is marred by dust and sweat and blood; who strives valiantly; who errs, who comes short again and again, because there is no effort without error and shortcoming; but who does actually strive to do the deeds; who knows great enthusiasms, the great devotions; who spends himself in a worthy cause; who at the best knows in the end the triumph of high achievement, and who at the worst, if he fails, at least fails while daring greatly, so that his place shall never be with those cold and timid souls who neither know victory nor defeat."

    President Theodore Roosevelt - Sorbonne, Paris, France
    April 23, 1910

    The above quote is a very small part of a speech titled "Citizenship in A Republic" sometimes it referred to as "Man in the Arena" in modern times.

    Many of our politicians and leaders would be well advised to read the speech in it's entirety today. It's about citizenship and just doing what is right and honorable at times when it's necessary. Not to worry about wining or losing, being on the right or wrong side ... just doing what is in your heart right, and do it the best as possible. Because if it's in your heart, and you do the best possible ... then you have won.

    ReplyDelete
  6. There seems to be a lack of many people taking this situation in Egypt and the remaining region as serious as it is.

    If the Brotherhood is not defeated in Egypt and they (Brotherhood) takes control of the central government, that will not be the end of this savage advancement by the Islam radicals, no Oh no. The beginning, not the end. let's all understand the end objective of the Brotherhood ... the TOTAL control of the Middle East, all the oil fields, Suez Canal, HE ELIMINATION OF THE STATE OF ISRAEL, etc, etc.

    The death and carnage that will be in the wake of their advancement will the "Killing Fields of Cambodia" via The Khmer Rouge & Pol Pot seem like a walk in the park.

    This is real stuff. we stop this onslaught here and now in Egypt, free the Egyptian people to live their lives as they see fit ... or we stop them in places like South East Asia, Southern Philippine Islands, Northern South & central America. Foreign place to most of you. How about European countries that have a quickly increasing Muslim population - France, Spain, Germany, Switzerland. All these countries have a Muslim population above 5% of their total plantation.

    We are all in this together. They see nothing but Islam and Infidels.

    "No man is an Island entire to itself. Everyman is a piece of the continent, part of the Main. So don't ask for whom the bells toll, they toll for you" as My Grandfathers Child said in part earlier.

    ReplyDelete
  7. Who was it said that civilization started in the Middle East and it will end in the Middle East???

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Don't know, but it appears we're out to prove that saying. I am worried about the silence from Iran right now

      Delete
  8. 25 Policemen savagely killed while being transported from one location to another over the weekend ... Let The Hunter games begin in Egypt.

    ReplyDelete