Saturday, June 22, 2013
The 21st Century Needs a Visionary Leader
Dear readers, this week has been filled with major events - riots in Turkey and Brazil, Syrian rebels receiving a nod from Barack Obama with his decision that the US will supply them with weapons, the Taliban and America fumbling their effort to get reconciliation talks started, a G8 meeting which saw Russia and the US in an arm wrestling contest over how to handle the future of al-Assad, and a major step in the long American debate about how to deal with the 10 million illegal immigrants already in the US and how to stop the inflow. When I consider all that's going on in our world right now, I keep coming back to basic questions - how to help people who are used to some form of democratic self-government govern themselves with civility and decorum, how to adapt people's natural but never-experienced desire for freedom into a government organized to respect both freedom and democratic desires while at the same time respecting culture and religion. I believe if we could answer these two fundamental questions, we would make the world a more peaceful and people-friendy place for everyone. But, I find very little being done to establish a framework for addressing them. There should be university chairs devoted to these issues and think tank units bringing experienced experts into the discussion. One of the problems with finding answers is that the world seems to have fallen into the habit of dividing people and countries along what I would call "We - They" lines. Some examples of this are : democracies vs all other forms of government, Christians and Jews vs Moslems, legal immigrants vs illegal immigrants, the world vs China, industrially developed countries vs non-industrially developed countries, rich nations vs poor nations. What seems to me to be wrong with looking at our world this way is that we suppress natural diversity of experience and thought processes. We thus encourage the dangerous "we - they" mentality that leads us to exclude everyone not exactly like us from the councils that make decisions for all of us. And the result is before our eyes, if we think about it - riots of poor people left out of the life they see on TV but cannot possibly achieve, "Arab Spring" insurrections when there is no other way to make political change, Tibetans immolating themselves as the only means they have to protest against the systematic destruction of their culture by foreign Chinese invaders, Americans calling for fences and mass evictions of illegal immigrants instead of trying to absorb them into a society that has always welcomed immigrants, small and less industrialized European countries being forced to create a culture and lifestyle that suits northern Germans but not Mediterranean Greeks or Spaniards. The examples seem endless. The results are always the same -- resentment on both sides of the we-they divide, suppressed anger that eventually spills out onto the streets, religious intolerance, a sense of frustration in world leaders because they don't know how to step across the unseen divide and so nothing seems to work. I am not a supporter of the 20th century's attempt to expand government so that people lose their sense of self-responsibility. People are responsible for their actions and for their lives. Government cannot and should not replace indivdual initiative. But - Athens had its Plato and Pericles, Europe had its Charlemagne, England had its Locke and Burke, America had its Jefferson and Lincoln. The 21st century desperately needs a visionary leader to guide the debate, hold out hope, find practical ways forward, love the people...all the people...of the world. Edmund Burke put it clearly 240 years ago : "I have no idea of a liberty unconnected with honesty and justice. Nor do I believe that any good constitutions of government, or of freedom, can find it necessary for their security to doom any part of the people to a permanent slavery."
Friday, June 21, 2013
America Inches toward Questionable Immigration Reform
The US Senate is close to an agreement to vastly increase fencing, patrols and high-tech monitoring along the US-Mexico border. The detailed amendment formally unveiled in the Senate makes it likely that a sweeping immigration bill, with the inclusion of the amendment, is headed for passage next week with substantial bipartisan support. President Obama also supports the bill. The new amendment adds thousands of patrol agents, hundreds of miles of fencing, and a budget of billions of dollars to be spent on everything from helicopters to drones to watchtowers. Republican Senators John Hoeven of North Dakota and Bob Corker of Tennessee were instrumental in drafting the amendment and getting GOP support lined up. "We really are trying to secure the border in a way that we hope can get bipartisan support and that Americans want," Senator Hoeven told the AP in a phone interview Friday. "We're hopeful to have a good bipartisan majority." Arizona Republican Senator John McCain said that "if there's anyone who still will argue that the border is not secure after this, then border security is not their reason for opposing a path to citizenship for the people who are in this country illegally." Hoeven developed the amendment along with Republican Senator Corker, in consultation with McCain, Senators Lindsey Graham, Chuck Schumer, and other members of the so-called Gang of Eight senators who wrote the immigration bill. It prevents immigrants now here illegally from attaining permanent resident status until a series of steps has been taken to secure the border. In addition to the border guards, the new amendment calls for unmanned surveillance drones, 350 miles of new pedestrian fencing to add to 350 miles already in place and an array of fixed and mobile devices to maintain vigilance, including high-tech tools such as infrared ground sensors and airborne radar. The timetable for implementation is 10 years, which matches the 10-year path to a permanent resident green card that the bill sets out for immigrants here illegally. During that time, the immigrants could live and work legally in a provisional status. Senator Hoeven said the 10-year cost of the border security amendment included $25 billion for the additional Border Patrol agents, $3 billion for fencing and $3.2 billion for other measures. Senators who had been uncommitted on the immigration bill are now prepared to support it, assuming the amendment is adopted. Senators Dean Heller and Mark Kirk announced their support for the deal Thursday. Republicans have insisted that green cards be made conditional on catching or turning back 90% of would-be border crossers. Schumer, other Democrats and Obama himself rejected this trigger, which they feared could delay the path to citizenship for years. The Democrat-Republican cooperation was made possible by a Congressional Budget Office report Tuesday concluding that the bill would cut billions of dollars from the deficit. Schumer's top immigration aide, Leon Fresco, had the idea of devoting some of those billions to a dramatic border buildup. With the budget office finding in place, Fresco met with Schumer and Corker and said, "OK, let's go big." The idea immediately appealed to the left and the right. For Republicans, it provided concrete assurances of seriously heightened border security. For Democrats, it offered achievable and measurable goals. ~~~~~ But, dear readers, there is no light at the end of the immigration tunnel just yet. Leading Republican opponents of the bill held a news conference to denounce the deal as little more than an empty promise. And the US House of Representatives, Republican-controlled and more conservative than the Senate, still has to pass its own immigration reform bill. When both the Senate and House bills have been passed, a joint House-Senate committee will try ro reconcile them. The one positive sign in all this is that everyone agrees that "something" has to be done. The choices range from a general 'amnesty' granting green card status to all illegal immigrants to forcng all illegals to go back to their country of origin and apply for admission under the current US visa program. The worrisome aspect of the Senate's beefed up border control program is that it has not worked to date and simply building a few hundred additional miles of fence and adding more border patrol capability looks to me like a game of mirrors and whistles to cover over the insurmountable problem of sealing a 2,000-mile land border when thousands of Mexicans and other Latin Americans are determined to get to America, whatever it takes.
Thursday, June 20, 2013
Afghan Taliban 3 - Obama/Kerry 0
Well, dear readers - another day and another twist in the bizarre efforts of the US Secretary of State, John Kerry, and his boss, President Obama, to get talks started with the Taliban as the first step in a reconciliation process for Afghanistan. Today it's about a prisoner exchange. The Afghan Taliban are ready to free a US soldier, US Army Sgt. Bowe Bergdahl, 27, held captive since 2009, in exchange for five senior Taliban operatives held at Guantanamo Bay. It would be a conciliatory gesture, a senior Taluban spokesman said on Thursday. The Taliban have consistently requested the release of Khairullah Khairkhwa, a former Taliban governor of Herat, and Mullah Mohammed Fazl, a former top Taliban military commander, both of whom have been held for more than a decade, as well as three others. We learned today that the prisoner exchange is the first item on the Taliban agenda and would be required before any opening peace talks could begin, according to a top Taliban leader, who said the prisoner exchange would build bridges of confidence to go forward. But, US Secretary of State John Kerry is expected to be in Qatar ahead of Saturday's conference on the Syrian civil war, and although he will not meet with the Taliban, it may be that lower level meetings will take place. On Wednesday in Washington, State Department spokeswoman Jen Psaki said the US had "never confirmed" any specific meeting schedule with Taliban representatives in Doha, the Qatar capital. Such prisoner exchanges have been controversial. Afghan President Karzai once scuttled a similar deal because he felt the Americans were usurping his authority. The current prisoner exchange possibility was raised by senior Taliban spokesman Shaheen Suhail in response to a question during a phone interview with the AP from the militants' newly opened political office in Doha. The US State Department is noncommittal about the proposal, which it said it had expected the Taliban to make. State Department spokeswoman Jen Psaki said. "We have not made a decision to ... transfer any Taliban detainees from Guantanamo Bay, but we anticipate, as I've said, that the Taliban will all raise this issue." The American captive, Bergdahl, of Hailey, Idaho, is the only known American soldier held captive from the Afghan war. He disappeared from his base in southeastern Afghanistan on June 30, 2009, and is believed to be held in Pakistan. Suhail said Bergdahl "is, as far as I know, in good condition." ~~~~~ So, let's try to summarize. The US wants to start talks with the enemy Afghan Taliban...but if they do, the American ally in Afghanistan, the government of President Karzai, will not participate. And, Karzai has already halted negotiztions with the US concerning US troop withdrawals and American advisors to continue in the country. But, in a move that seemed unknown to Obama's team, the Taliban went to Qatar and opened an office using their official name during the period when they ruled Afghanistan. So Qatar had to convince them to take dowm their sign and replace it because America and Karzai and the Afghan people were offended. The Taliban complied. But the next day they told AP - not the US, their erstwhile negotiating partner - that before negotiations could begin, a prisoner exchange would be required as an act of good faith. This was unknown to the Americans but the US State Department said it was not unexpected. ~~~~~ Items still to be worked out in the glare of the international media : the color of the team uniforms and the shape of the negotiating table. Do you suppose, dear readers, that a pause is in order - to give the Kerry-Obama side time to brush up on "Negotiating 101" ? Otherwise, America may wake up one morning to find that the Afghan Taliban now own the Washington Monument.
Wednesday, June 19, 2013
Obama's Unprecedented Afghanistan Faux Pas
Afghanistan President Hamid Karzai said Wednesday he will not enter into peace talks with the Taliban unless the United States steps out of the negotiations. He also insisted the Taliban stop its violent attacks on the ground after it claimed responsibility for a rocket attack that killed four Americans. The Taliban said on Wednesday it was responsible for the attack on the Bagram Air Base in which four American troops were killed. American officials confirmed the base had come under attack by indirect fire - mortar or rocket - and that four US troops were killed. Karzai's strong response and the Taliban attack undercut hopes for the start of talks to end 12 years of war in Afghanistan. All this occurred just one day after the US and the Taliban said they would begin initial meetings in Qatar. Karzai had said Tuesday that he would send his High Peace Council to Qatar for talks but aides said he changed his mind after objecting to the way the announcement was handled, in particular the Taliban's use of its formal name "Islamic Emirate of Afghanistan" in opening an office in Doha. President Barack Obama had cautioned Tuesday that the peace talks with the Taliban would be neither quick nor easy but that their opening a political office in Doha was an "important first step toward reconciliation" between the Islamic militants and the government of Afghanistan. Karzai's High Peace Council had been expected to follow up with its own talks with the Taliban a few days later but it is now unclear whether that will happen. Shafiullah Nooristani, a member of the High Peace Council, told the AP that the use of the name violated agreements Karzai's government had made with the US and caused diplomatic issues for Afghanistan. He said negotiations with the Taliban should not make it seem as if they are a political entity like a parallel institution to the Afghan Embassy which is already there. "The agreement was that the office should open only - and only - for negotiations, not as a political entity," Nooristan said. But as of now, it is not clear that the Taliban will be forced to change the name they are using in Qatar. President Karzai also suspended on Wednesday - to protest the way his government was being left out of initial peace negotiations with the Taliban - talks with the US on a new security deal meant to find ways to end the war. Karzai said negotiations with the US on which American and coalition security forces will remain in the country after 2014 have been put on hold. The two Afghan announcements were issued while Obama was trying to appease Karzai, with Obama telling reporters during a visit to Berlin that "ultimately we're going to need to see Afghans talking to Afghans." "But they've been fighting there for a long time" and mistrust is rampant, Obama said, explaining why he thinks it is important to pursue a parallel track toward reconciliation even as the fighting continues, and it would be up to the Afghan people whether that effort ultimately bears fruit. ~~~~~ It is one thing, dear readers, to lose a war by negotiating away the rights of the side you have been supporting. But it is quite another thing - and perhaps unprecedented - to actually forget to keep in place the public facade of pretending to fight for their rights even as you negotiate them away. It is the latest faux pas in the incompetent foreign affairs record of the Obama administration. It leaves yet another gaping hole in the already-riddled Middle East non-policy of President Obama. One has to wonder how many Obama follies the unstable and agitated region can take before it explodes into a thousand wars in the realization that nobody cares about saving it.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)