Thursday, June 13, 2013

Syria - the World's Blind Spot

The UN Human Rights Commission reported today that it has confirmed at least 93,000 deaths in the Syrian civil war. But the UN High Commissioner for Human Rights said it was impossible to provide an exact number, which could be far higher. The latest report adds more confirmed killings to the previous time period and an additional 27,000 between December and April. And the outrageous truth buried in these numbers is that 6,500 children have been killed - 1,600 of them under the age of 10. Also this week, US officials had hoped to reach a decision on arming Syria's rebels but they are still uncertain whether that's the best way to reshape a war that now includes Lebanon's Hezbollah and Iranian fighters supporting Assad's armed forces, and al-Qaida-linked extremists backing the opposition. AP reports that President Barack Obama and his national security team are "greatly concerned" by the worsening situation in Syria, according to White House spokesman Jay Carney. Obama continues to review and consider additional options for US involvement, Carney said, adding that he expects Syria will be discussed at the Group of Eight summit next week in Northern Ireland. ~~~~~ Dear readers, let's review again the surreal state of affairs in Syria. The rebel forces were chased from a stronghold, Qusair, last week - the last defenders fleeing through fields as al-Assad forces pursued. More than 100 were killed, and some died despite doctors and nurses in the fleeing contingent, because they lacked the ordinary medical equipment and medicines that could easily have saved lives. The loss of Qusair leaves al-Assad and Hezbollah in command of one of two vital rebel supply lines linking southern Syria and Lebanon. It also leaves Hezbollah in a position of strength in both Syria and along the borders with Israel, which is once again facing the very real prospect of Hezbollah attack with Iranian supplied weapons. The Iranian weapons could soon include nuclear bombs, if the West continues to confront the possibility of a nuclear Iran the way it is now confronting the Syrian disaster. Meanwhile the disheartened rebels are preparing to defend the routes northward toward Aleppo, their other stronghold and supply route. Al-Assad forces are already in the region around Homs, although the rebel force took a military installation after a pitched battle this week. The rebel command also hit the Damascus airport today, a first. But, it would appear that the Syrian rebels have abandoned hope of western arms and they say they are looking to jihadist groups for these gravely needed weapons without which they cannot win..~~~~~ The American, European and UN handling of the Syria civil war may be the worst example ever of the inability of the international community to decide what it believes or how to act on the few core beliefs that actually remain as the fiber binding them together as human beings. Words fail me.

Wednesday, June 12, 2013

Barack Obama, Pope Francis and the Will to Lead

Apparently there really is a "gay lobby" in the Vatican, as La Reppublica newspaper in Rome has reported and a Vatican spokesman has denied, characterizing the reports as defamatory, "unverified, unverifiable or completely false." It may be time for the Vatican to reconsider its commentary because no less a perspn than Pope Francis recently lamented that a "gay lobby" was at work at the Vatican. He made the comment in private remarks to the leadership of a key Latin American church group - a stunning revelation that appears to confirm the earlier reports about corruption and dysfunction in the Holy See. The group, known by its Spanish acronym CLAR, said it was greatly distressed that a document it had prepared to summarize the encounter with Pope Francis had been published and apologized to the Pope. The CLAR report appeared Tuesday in Spanish on the progressive Chilean-based website "Reflection and Liberation" and was picked up and translated by the blog Rorate Caeli, which is read in Vatican circles. In the report, Pope Francis is quoted as being remarkably forthcoming about his administrative shortcomings, saying he was relying on the group of eight cardinals he appointed to lead a reform of the Vatican bureaucracy. Earlier, the gay lobby had been accused of something that sounds a lot like blackmail - that is, using information it has about gay Vatican bureaucrats to influence papal decision-making. It has been suggested to be one of the reasons Benedict decided to resign. Italian journalists have also said details of the scandal were laid out in the secret dossier prepared for Benedict by three trusted cardinals who investigated the leaks of papal documents last year. Benedict left the dossier for Francis. The Vatican spokesman said he could make no comment about rhe Pope's remarks because it was a private meeting and as a result he had nothing to say. The members of CLAR said no recording had been made of Francis' remarks but that the members of its leadership team - a half-dozen men and women from religious orders - together wrote a synthesis of the points he had made for their own personal use. ~~~~~ Dear readers, if we combine the Pope's gay lobby remarks with his recent comment that he did not want to be Pope, and his statement that he is relying on a committee to reform the Vatican - a picture is emerging of a priest who is as much an outsider at the Vatican as Barack Obama is an outsider in Washington. That comparison may seem odd, but it points to a real similarity in the problem the Vatican and the American federal government face. They are both the titular headquarters of a far-flung political system. The Catholic Church. The United States. Both headquarters are run by consummate insiders who pretty much do as they please because their constituencies have no evident mechanism to stay current with their policies and actions - and their oversight institutions, the Pope and the US Congress, are usually insiders, too. The last Pope, Benedict XVI, was an outsider who finally resigned, undoubtedly because the gay lobby was just one of many insider groups who made it impossible for him to function because he didn't understand the insider "codes." President Obama has only one major success in five years. Obamacare. And he largely left it to the Democrat Congress to achieve it. Just as Francis is leaving the badly needed Vatican reform, a major reason for his election to the papacy, to insiders. These are two leaders who have their noses pressed to the candyshop window, watching others eat the candy that ought to belong to them. It is too late for President Obama to do anything but survive - if he can avoid the darker scenarios related to the deluge of scandals washing over his administration. But Pope Francis is new on the job and he should stop talking about how he doesn't want to be Pope. He should move into the papal apartments, if for no other reason than as a show of authority. He should take personal control of the Vatican bureaucracy and bend it to his will - his immense popularity should make this possible. And he should understand that he has been called to a vitally important mission - preserving Christianity by making it relevant to the 21st century. Francis can do this. The question is - does he have the will and the force of character to bring it off. I truly hope he does.

Tuesday, June 11, 2013

Our World, Plato and Mandela

I feel sure, dear readers, that you must have the same thoughts I have - the world is a violent mess. People seem to gave forgotten how to live in peace, showing tolerance and love for their neighbors, their fellow countrymen and the wider world. Perhaps it was never quite as peaceful as we remember, but there were fewer violent confrontations surely. But I do not place blame on entirely either on people or on governments. More than two thousand years ago Plato said : "Excess generally causes reaction, and produces a change in the opposite direction whether it be in the seasons, or in individuals, or in governments." He could be describing 2013. For today, we are witnesses to a great chasm between governed and governors, between conservatives and socialists, between Christians and Moslems, between rich and poor, between young and old, between democrats and tyrants. Plato also observed that "The people have always some champion whom they set over them and nurse into greatness… This and no other is the root from which a tyrant springs, when he first appears he is a protector." This is perhaps the common thread in all of the opposing forces of the 21st century. Every society, every popular cause, every nation and every religion raises someone to icon status - this is not new but it is exaggerated today because of the instant communication in our Internet world. I cannot imagine that we are being led by men and women who are seriously inferior to those of ancient Rome, or who are more violent than the rulers of the Middle Ages or Renaissance. Our leaders are, for the most part, less violent and more toletant of oppositions. But they age fast because they are constantly in the eye of the media and dissected on the Internet. Again Plato -- "Good people do not need laws to tell them to act responsibly, while bad people will find way around the laws." And are we not also subject daily to the evil deeds of bad people because of the same media and Internet? Our reaction as 'normal' citizens is to demand absolute perfection in our leaders and to turn violently on those whose violence we detest. This can only make matters worse because perfection does not exist in human beings - so every leader will fail - and violence begets violence - until everyone is mired in the same sub-human mud and the formerly non-violent no longer recognize themselves. But through it all, we clamor for liberty, for complete freedpm of action and for government to become our nanny at the same time that we demand that it disappear from our daily lives. Not an easy puzzle to solve, is it? Two hundred years ago, Edmund Burke addressed these issues : "Liberty, too, must be limited in order to be possessed. The degree of restraint it is impossible in any case to settle precisely. But it ought to be the constant aim of every wise public council to find out by cautious experiments, and rational cool endeavours, with how little, not how much, of this restraint the community can subsist; for liberty is a good to be improved, and not an evil to be lessened. It is not only a private blessing of the first order, but the vital spring and energy of the state itself, which has just so much life and vigour as there is liberty in it. But whether liberty be advantageous or not (for I know it is a fashion to decry the very principle), none will dispute that peace is a blessing; and peace must, in the course of human affairs, be frequently bought by some indulgence and toleration at least to liberty for as the sabbath (though of divine institution) was made for man, not man for the sabbath, government, which can claim no higher origin or authority, in its exercise at least, ought to conform to the exigencies of the time, and the temper and character of the people with whom it is concerned, and not always to attempt violently to bend the people to their theories of subjection. The bulk of mankind on their part, are not excessively curious concerning any theories whilst they are really happy; and one sure symptom of an ill-conducted state is the propensity of the people to resort to them." Burke wrote this in a letter to British sheriffs. ~~~~~ Dear readers, these thoughts come to me from two very different fronts -- there is the uproar over the US government's Internet sweeps that certainly violate personal liberty, but at least in part as a response to the demand of its citizens to be protected from terrorists. And there is Nelson Mandela, struggling to hold on to life in a battle every bit as fierce as the battle he waged on Robben Island against fear and maltreatment and despair. He is in a sense the embodiment of our own struggles against violence and dehumanization at the hands of evil. We will lose Madiba one day. But we should hold fast to his spirit of love for his fellow human beings, to his sense that reconciliatipn is the only way to overcome violent opposing forces, to his belief that talking to your enemy is the only way forward. In this he echoes Lincoln, who tried always to persuade Americans North and South to be friends and brothers and not to be enemies. As Plato said, "Be kind, for everyone you meet is fighting a hard battle."

Monday, June 10, 2013

US Government Internet Spying

WHAT WE HAVE BEEN TOLD ABOUT U.S. INTERNET SPYING : Details about the US government's secret phone call and email sweep continue to be revealed, while President Obama, anxious to calm American outrage over the US spying on them, as they see it, defended the counterterrorism methods on Friday and said Americans need to "make some choices" in balancing privacy and security. Meanwhile, Director of National Intelligence James Clapper took the rare step of declassifying details of the programs to respond to media reports about counterterrorism techniques employed by the government. He stressed Saturday that the previously undisclosed program for tapping into Internet usage is authorized by Congress, falls under strict supervision of a secret court and cannot intentionally target a US citizen. Clapper was obviously angered by the revelation of the intelligence-gathering program, calling it reckless. "Disclosing information about the specific methods the government uses to collect communications can obviously give our enemies a 'playbook' of how to avoid detection," he said in a prepared statement. But the President's response and Clapper's public disclosures are a response to the national malaise, as well as Obama's sensitivity to any suggestion that he is trampling on the civil liberties of Americans. Clapper declassified some details of the NSA phone records collection program that obtains from phone companies on an "ongoing, daily basis" the records of its customers' calls. Clapper said that under the court-supervised program, only a small fraction of the records collected are ever examined because most are unrelated to any possible terrorism activity. His statement and declassification Saturday also addressed the Internet retrieval program, code-named PRISM, that allows NSA and the FBI to tap directly into the servers of major US Internet companies, such as Google, Apple, Microsoft, Facebook and AOL. Unlike the phone call sweep program, PRISM allows the government to seize actual conversations: emails, video chats, instant messages and more. Clapper said the program, engaged in under the USA Patriot Act, has been in place since 2008, under the George W. Bush administration, and "has proven vital to keeping the nation and our allies safe. They are important tools for the protection of the nation's security," he said. Clapper revealed that PRISM activity requires approval from a FISA Court judge and is conducted with the knowledge of the provider that supplies information when legally required to do so. PRISM seeks foreign intelligence information concerning foreign targets reasonably believed to be located outside the United States. It cannot intentionally target any US citizen or any person known to be in the US. Using data related to a US person is prohibited unless it is "necessary to understand foreign intelligence or assess its importance, is evidence of a crime, or indicates a threat of death or serious bodily harm." The Washington Post and Guardian citation of classified slides and other PRISM documents in their published reports that named major companies whose data has been obtained has thus been corroborated by Clapper. The newspaper reports also indicate that PRISM has opened a door for NSA to tap directly on the companies' data centers whenever the government chooses. The Guardian obtained top-secret documents detailing an NSA tool, called Boundless Informant, that maps the information it collects from computer and telephone networks by country. The paper said the documents show that NSA collected almost 3 billion pieces of intelligence from US computer networks over a 30-day period ending in March, which the paper says raises questions about the truth of NSA statements that it cannot determine how many Americans may be accidentally included in its computer surveillance. NSA spokesperson Judith Emmel said Saturday that "current technology simply does not permit us to positively identify all of the persons or locations associated with a given communication." She said it may be possible to determine that a communication "traversed a particular path within the Internet," but added that "it is harder to know the ultimate source or destination, or more particularly the identity of the person represented by the TO:, FROM: or CC: field of an e-mail address or the abstraction of an IP address." Emmel said communications are filtered both by automated processes and NSA staff to make sure Americans' privacy is respected. "This is not just our judgment, but that of the relevant inspectors general, who have also reported this," she said. The revelations have divided Congress and led civil liberties advocates and some constitutional scholars to accuse Obama of crossing a constitutionally-prohibited line in the name of rooting out terror threats. Experts both inside and outside the government predict that potential attackers will find other ways to communicate now that they know that their phone and Internet records may be targeted. An al-Qaida affiliated website warned its readers on Saturday not to send through the Internet details of militant activities in three long articles on what it called "America's greatest and unprecedented scandal" of spying on its own citizens and people in other countries. Former Representative Pete Hoekstra, who served on the House Intelligence Committee for a decade, said "the bad folks' antennas go back up and they become more cautious for a period of time." And he added that the government will develop more sophisticated ways to dig into these data. It becomes a techies game, and we will try to come up with new tools to cut through the clutter," he said. Hoekstra said he approved the phone surveillance program but did not know about PRISM online spying. ~~~~~ Dear readers, this is a lot to absorb. Think about it. If you are an American citizen, you may want to consider whether your government has created an Orwellian 1984 mechanism that could watch you and perhaps control your life. Of all the information to sift through in today's blog, the hardest to believe is the statement of Judith Emmel, NSA spojespetson, who said : "...it may be possible to determine that a communication 'traversed a particular path within the Internet,...it is harder to know the ultimate source or destination, or more particularly the identity of the person represented by the TO:, FROM: or CC: field of an e-mail address or the abstraction of an IP address.' " If this statement is accurate, why is the government risking its credibility to trawl the Internet? We will consider this and other personal liberty questions another day.